Kimberly Nicholas
Senior Lecturer, Docent
Does Voluntary Governance Work? : Insights from Specialty Coffee
Author
Summary, in English
My research indicates that voluntary market-based regulatory initiatives could contribute to governance for sustainability through involving businesses and consumers in governance, but that there are limitations. The limitations of this approach were showcased by the inability of US direct trade founders to enforce common definitions of direct trade due to the voluntary nature of the initiative and the inability or unwillingness of private actors to enforce definitions, in part due to perceived self-interest. This shows how such initiatives can have difficulty penalizing or using disincentives to inspire change. Direct trade scheme developments demonstrated the active inclusion of consumers within regulatory governance, but this active role was pushed on consumers rather than requested by consumers. In addition, there were indications of limitations of consumer skill in differentiating between regulatory schemes. Sustainability reporting among US specialty coffee roasters reveals poor conditions for empowerment through disclosure as disclosed information is not comprehensive, comparable, or useful because too few companies report and those that do report disclose information inconsistently. Collaboratively defined material topics, such as the goals and measurements defined within the Sustainable Coffee Challenge, do have the potential to improve the quality and usefulness of voluntary disclosures for governance, although it is too soon to say whether this has worked in practice. Finally, both voluntary certification and disclosure involving businesses focus on problem solving and avoid broader sustainability strategies such as substituting coffee with a more sustainable alternative or trying to decrease coffee consumption.
Department/s
- LUCSUS (Lund University Centre for Sustainability Studies)
Publishing year
2017
Language
English
Full text
Document type
Licentiate thesis
Publisher
Lund University
Topic
- Social Sciences Interdisciplinary
Keywords
- regulatory governance
- sustainability science
- voluntary governance
- certification
- disclosure
- sustainability reporting
- coffee
- Reglering och styrning
- hållbarhetsvetenskap
- frivillig reglering
- certifiering
- rapportering
- kaffe
Status
Published
Project
- LUCID - Lund University Centre of Excellence for Integration of Social and Natural Dimensions of Sustainability
Research group
- LUCID - Lund University Centre of Excellence for Integration of Social and Natural Dimensions of Sustainability
Supervisor
- Lennart Olsson
- Kimberly Nicholas
ISBN/ISSN/Other
- ISBN: 978-91-982201-4-8
- ISBN: 978-91-982201-3-1
Defence date
29 September 2017
Defence time
11:00
Defence place
Ostrom, Josephson, Biskopsgatan 5, Lund
Opponent
- Lin Lerpold (Associate professor)